China’s Cultural Reverse Course: From Independence to Patronage in Unofficial Media Production

Matthew D. Johnson writes about the current state of documentaries in China

Written by Matthew D. Johnson. The article was initially published on the webpage of the China Policy Institute.

It has become obvious to many that China is undergoing a reverse course away from cultural openness and toward ideological closure. Universities, the Internet, social media, religion, and NGOs have all been made targets of a Xi Jinping-directed effort to exert greater political control over institutions with the potential to shape social values within the People’s Republic of China (PRC). The impact of this process, which I have written about elsewhere as a process of cultural securitization has also been felt within the world of independent documentary cinema. As a result, unofficial production of knowledge about contemporary social realities has become increasingly depoliticized or, perhaps less visibly, embedded within networks of political patronage. The Xi-ist state has not squeezed unofficial image-making out of existence. Rather, it has eliminated weaker forms while simultaneously giving rise to the existence of a more limited, institutionalized pluralism existing within the body of the party-state itself.

CONDITIONAL INDEPENDENCE: UNOFFICIAL DOCUMENTARY PRODUCTION AND ELITE PATRONAGE


At the end of February 2015 a new documentary appeared on PRC video websites. "Under the Dome" (Qiongding Zhixia) was a 104-minute film which documented, in devastating fashion, the effects of China’s air pollution on the environment, was made by former China Central Television (CCTV) investigative reporter Chai Jing. The focus of the documentary was urban smog, and discussion of its message soon spread to media outlets both PRC and foreign. Chai claimed to have decided to make and finance the documentary herself after her baby daughter was diagnosed with a tumor. The film was screened in Beijing on February 27 and made available online the next day. Within two days it had been viewed by hundreds of millions of people, and was cited as a successful example of a citizen-sparked “awareness campaign.”

The documentary was publicly praised by the PRC’s new minister of environmental protection Chen Jining, and in the online edition of People’s Daily.  Bloggers also responded enthusiastically to Under the Dome, in part for its role in sparking an online national discussion concerning GDP-first economic policies. (Also raised were details concerning Chai’s personal life, such as her alleged smoking, as well as challenges to the data used and recommendations presented.) However, on March 1 PRC government authorities were already instructing media outlets to refrain from promoting the film, and to regulate or “adjust” (调控) public opinion surrounding it.  On the eve of the annual meeting of the “two sessions” (The National People’s Congress and Chinese People’s Political Consultative Congress) on March 3, 2015 orders to remove all coverage of the film and its creator, and any related content, from PRC websites and mobile services began to appear at the lower levels of the propaganda system and on Weibo.  On March 6 the order for full deletion of the video appeared, at which point "Under the Dome" was removed from the websites of major internet video portals Youku and Tencent, as well as from the People’s Daily webpage where it had originally debuted online.

Whether or not "Under the Dome" was ultimately an elite-backed project remains a topic of some debate. What is clearer is that Chai Jing’s glossy documentary is only one of several independently made, environmentally focused productions in the tradition of 1980s problem-centered reportage literature (以问题为中心的报告文学) released in past years, another being Wang Jiuliang’s 2011 "Beijing Encircled by Trash" (Laji Weicheng).  Wang’s documentary, in production since 2008, presents a stark portrayal of the PRC’s ever-expanding landfills and scavenger economy from the perspective of garbage dumps beyond Beijing’s Seventh Ring Road. It is safe to say that Wang is not a beloved figure in the eyes of the city’s municipal authorities. Still, he continues to distribute his film internationally (New York City-based dGenerate Films currently lists Wang’s work on their website), and has traveled internationally to discuss and promote his work; within the PRC, Wang’s landfill photojournalism has earned the director an award at the Guangdong government-sponsored Lianzhuo International Photography Festival and an interview with China Daily.  For media professionals like Chai and Wang, independent-mindedness and exposure of national problems has not resulted in censorship or worse—to the contrary, both Chai and Wang have thrived as flashpoints for popular outrage concerning environmental degradation and, what is more, seem to have the tacit support of officials at various ranks of China’s government.


CONTRASTING PATTERNS OF PERMISSIVENESS AND SUPPRESSION: DOCUMENTARY ORAL HISTORY

Like the environment, history has become a controversial subject under Xi Jinping’s government. Scholarly debates over China’s 1950s and 1960s famines and the expansionist ambitions of the Qing dynasty have become acrimoniously politicized. Those who view history through a critical lens are accused of espousing Westernization and “historical nihilism” (历史虚无主义); those arguing for a more uplifting view argue that history must serve the greater national good by functioning as patriotic education. One of the most literally visible ways in which history and historical debate are spilling over into independent media is through the activity of independent filmmakers like Hu Jie and Wu Wenguang, both of whom have made oral histories of the Mao years a focal point in their respective bodies of work. However, state responses to the resulting documentation of personal testimony concerning famine and political turbulence have varied. In explaining these divergent outcomes, the key differences appear to be whether the directors themselves have shown themselves willing to cooperate with party-state agendas, or to elicit tacit support and sympathy from within the government.

In Hu’s case, the fact that his films have attracted interest primarily among overseas viewers means that his focus on past CCP abuses of intellectuals seems to create embarrassment and frustration for the state. The work of Hu’s which has most aroused official ire is "In Search of Lin Zhao’s Soul" (Xuzhao Lin Zhao de Linghun), a film about a young student executed in 1958 for her unspoken ideas. News of the 2005 film spread in China, particularly among the dissident community, resulting in attempts to visit her grave on the anniversary of her death.  The timing of the anniversary, on April 29, increased sensitivities due to its relative proximity to the anniversaries of Hu Yaobang’s death and the June 4 Massacre. By contrast, most unofficial historians do not work in audiovisual media, and their work is by legal necessity circulated only among small circles of like-minded amateur historians. (Actual circulation of e-journals  such as Remembrance [Jiyi] and Yesterday [Zuotian] is likely wider than state limits allow, but such recirculation activity occurs “underground,” and is difficult for both authorities and observers to track.) Hu is a former state media agency employee who has worked for the Xinhua news network. Nonetheless, working outside of any circles of official influence, he has faced intimidating surveillance (wire taps, visits from security personnel) and travel restrictions for his forays into particularly sensitive areas such as China’s Anti-Rightist campaigns and Cultural Revolution.


By way of contrast, independent documentary filmmaker Wu Wenguang has also been working on a history of the Leap and famine from a bottom-up perspective, though with considerably less official interference. The difference in outcomes appears to lie in each director’s personal networks. Wu’s "Folk Memory Project"(Minjian Jiyi Jihua) tells the story of the Great Leap Forward through a series of interviews with villagers conducted by more than 100 young interviewers; the project has run continuously since 2010. Yet unlike Hu Jie, and despite his reputation in international film circles as a rebel and anti-state critic, Wu’s film oeuvre prior to the Folk Memory project has never delved into taboo or heavy politicized subjects, focusing instead on the experiences of marginal individuals drawn from contemporary PRC society.  In addition, Wu’s earlier production of another multi-contributor documentary endeavor, the "China Village Documentary Project" was initially carried out in part through cooperation with the PRC Ministry of Civil Affairs and the European Commission, which together supported the filmmaking in its early stages as part of the EU-China Training Programme on Village Governance.  In comparison with Hu Jie, Wu Wenguang’s work is located more within the boundaries of state-permitted discourse, and Wu’s career shows evidence of tacit cooperation with state agendas in order to further his activities as a producer of independent media.

Matthew D. Johnson is Executive Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences, Taylor’s University, Malaysia. He is a co-founder, director, and editor of The PRC History Group (http://prchistory.org/) and The PRC History Review (http://prchistory.org/prc-history-review/). He has followed independent cinema and music in China since trading for his first 零点乐队 tape in 1997. His previous writing for CPI: Analysis has covered historical and contemporary state propaganda and the future direction of China’s post-Xi reforms.

Image Credit: CC by arianta/Flickr.

COMMENTS

Name

13 Assassins,1,2017,3,A Company Man,1,A few words about us,1,A Lonely Cow Weeps at Dawm,1,A Love,1,A Man Vanishes,1,A Simple Life,1,A Single Rider,1,A Stone from Another Mountain to Polish Your Own Stone. Go Shibata,1,A Tale of Love,1,A Whale of a Tale,1,About Elly,1,Adam J. Symchuk,20,Adam John,6,Aditya Vikram Sengupta,1,Adriana Rosati,4,Age of Innocence,1,Akihiko Shiota,1,Akira Kurosawa,1,Akiyuki Shinbo,1,Ale Amout,1,Alex Oost,1,Alexander Knoth,1,Ali Asghar Vadayeh Kheiri,1,Amir Masoud Aghababeian,1,Amitabh Reza,1,Anand Singh,2,Andrew Thayne,4,Andy Willis,1,Anime,1,Animesh Aich,1,Ann Hui,1,Anna Bliss,3,Anshul Chauhan,2,Anurag Basu,1,Aqerat,1,Arang,1,Ariyuki Shinbo,1,Armour of God,1,Arrow,2,Art Film Fest Kosice,1,Article Films,1,Asghar Farhadi,1,Asha Jaoar Majhe,1,Asian Classics,19,Aya Itabe,1,Aynabaji,1,Bad Poetry Tokyo,4,BAMY,1,Bangkok Nites,1,Bangladesh,3,Banjong Pisanthanakun,1,Banmei Takahashi,1,Before We Vanish,1,Behind the Camera,1,Belgium,1,Ben Stykuc,5,Bengal,1,Bhutan,1,Billy Joe,2,Black,1,Bloody Muscle Builder in Hell,1,Bollywood,1,Branded to Kill,2,Breathless,1,Burma,1,Burning Birds,2,Bystanders,1,Cambodia,2,Camera Japan,10,Children Heaven,1,China,6,Chinese Policy Institute,6,Chinese Visual Festival,1,Choi Jin-ho,1,Choi Jin-won,1,Chris Berry,1,Chu Yuan,1,Chungking Express,1,Close-Knit,1,Coffeemates,1,Colette Balmain,7,Competition,1,Confessions,1,Creative Visions: Hong Kong Cinema,1,Crocodile,1,Crows Zero,1,Cyrano Agency,1,Daguerreotype,1,Daigo Matsui,1,Daisuke Gotô,2,Daisuke Miyazaki,3,David Chew,3,David Chew.,1,David Shin,1,Ddongpari,1,Dead Friend,1,Dead Sushi,1,Deadly Outlaw: Rekka,1,Deepak Rauniyar,1,Destruction Babies,1,Diary of June,1,Digger,1,Ding Shen,1,Dismembered,1,Documentaries,6,Documentary,2,Doenjang,1,Don Anelli,18,Double Life,1,Dr. Heo,1,drama,1,Duelist,1,East Winds Film Festival,1,Edmund Yeo,3,Educating Yuna,1,Eiji Uchida,1,Emmanuel Horlaza,1,Erotic Diary of an Office Lady,1,Eureka,2,Exploitation,25,Fabricated City,1,Faye Wong,1,Features,18,Feautures,1,Fel,8,Festivals,5,Filmdoo,6,Fireworks,1,Fireworks Should We See It from the Side or the Bottom?,1,Five Flavors Festival,2,Five Flavours Festival,3,Flying Fish,1,Forgetting Vietnam,1,France,1,Fraser Elliott,1,Funeral Parade of Roses,1,Fuyuhiko Nishi,1,Gillian Anderson,1,Golden Horse Awards,1,Good -Bye Silence,1,Goro Miyazaki,1,Hanagatami,1,Hanuman,1,Hashiguchi Takaaki,1,Haunters,1,Helsinki Cine Aasia Festival 2018,1,Hidden Gems,34,Hideo Sakaki,1,High-Kick Girl,1,Hindi,1,Hirokazu Koreeda,3,Hiroshi Ando,1,Hiroshi Teshigahara,1,Hong Kong,4,Horror,2,I Wish,1,I-Lin Liu,8,ICA,3,Im Kyeong-soo,1,Imran Firdaus,1,In this Corner of the World,3,Indonesia,4,Interview,1,Interviews,23,Intimate Confessions of a Chinese Courtesan,1,Inugami,1,Iran,7,Ishmael Bernal,1,Isora Iwakiri,1,Jackie Chan,2,Jagga Jasoos,1,James Mudge,1,Japan,117,Japan Cuts,14,Japan Filmfest Hamburg,1,Japanese Film Festival Australia,1,Jeong Jae-eun,1,Jess Teong,1,Jimmy Henderson,2,Jithin K Mohan,1,Joe Odagiri,2,Johnnie To,1,Joko Anwar,1,Jonathan Wilson,6,Joo Ji-hong,1,Journey of the Tortoise,1,Jun Tanaka,1,Jung Yoon-suk,1,Junichi Kajioka,1,Junpei Mizusaki,1,K-dramas,12,Kaneto Shindo,1,Kang Je-gyu,1,Kang Yoon-Sung,1,Katsuya Tomita,1,kdrama,1,Kei Chikaura,1,Kei Ishikawa,1,Kengo Yagawa,1,Kenichi Ugana,1,Kill me,1,Killing Beauty,1,Kim Eun-hee,1,Kim Hong-seon,1,Kim Hyun-seok,1,Kim Jee-woon,1,Kim Ki-duk,1,Kim Kih-hoon,1,Kim Min Su kII,1,Kim Min-suk,1,Kim Tae-kyeong,1,Kingyo,2,Kirti Raj Singh,1,Kiss me,1,Kiyoshi Kurosawa,3,Koji Wakamatsu,1,Komiya Masatetsu,1,Kon Ichikawa,1,Konrad Aderer,1,Korea,1,korean drama,1,Krzysztof Pietrzak,1,Kun-Yu Lai,2,Kwak Kyung-taek,1,Kyoko Miyake,1,Kyriacos Kyriacou,2,Lady Snowblood,2,Laos,1,Lee Je-Yong,1,Lee Joo-young,1,Lee Jung-sun,1,Lee Myung-se,1,Lee Seo-goon,1,Leung Wing-Fai,1,Like Father,1,Like Son,1,Lim Sang-yoon,1,Lists,11,Little Big Soldier,1,Live Up To Your Name,1,Loi Bao,1,Los Angeles Indian Festival,1,Love,1,Lovers Are Wet,1,Lowlife Love,1,Lyberis,2,Madman,1,Mahde Hasan,1,Majid Majidi,1,Makoto Shinkai,1,Malaysia,5,Maria Georgiou,18,Mark Gallagher,1,Masaki Adachi,1,Masanori Tominaga,1,Masaru Konume,1,Masato Harada,1,Masatoshi Kurakata,1,Matt Cooper,9,Matthew D. Johnson,1,Maundy Thursday,1,Mermaid,1,Midi Z,1,Midori Impuls,3,Milk the Maid,1,Minoru Kunizawa,1,Miwa Nishikawa,1,Mohammad-Reza Lotfi,1,Mongolia,1,Moon Lovers,1,Mototsugu Watanabe,4,Movie,1,Mr. Socrates,1,My Dad and Mr Ito,1,My Hero Chihiro,1,Myanmar,1,Nanachan,1,Naoko Ogigami,1,Naomi Kawase,1,Naosuke Kurosawa,1,Naoyuki Tomomatsu,3,Neko Atsume House,1,Nepal,1,New Neighbor,2,News,1,Nicholas Poly,3,Nikola Cekic,1,Niwatsukino Norihiro,1,Noboru Iguchi,1,Nobuhiko Obayashi,2,Nobuhiro Yamashita,2,Nobuo Nakagawa,1,Nobuyuki Takeuchi,1,Noise,2,Non-fiction Diary,1,Norman England,2,Nurse Diary: Beast Afternoon,1,NYAFF,7,Nyamdavaa Baasansuren,1,Oh In-Chun,1,Old Boy,2,Omar Rasya Joenoes,3,On The Line Festival,2,Ophilia,1,Orson McClellan Mochizuki,1,Osaka Asian Film Festival,4,Osamu Sato,1,Our Happy time,1,Over the Fence,1,Pai Kau,1,Palatpol Mingpornpichit,1,Panos Kotzathanasis,57,Park Chan-wook,2,Park Ki- hyung,1,Park Kwang-hyun,1,Parkpoom Wongpoom,1,Pedro Morata,3,Peerachai Kerdsint,1,Pen-Ek Ratanaruang,1,Peng Xiaolian,1,Peque Gallaga,1,Philippines,1,Pieter - Jan Van Haecke,3,Pieter-Jan Van Haecke,7,Pink Eiga,14,PinkEiga.TV,6,pinku eiga,1,Psychic,1,Pumpkin and Mayonnaise,1,Rabbit and Lizard,1,Railway Sleepers,1,Raja Mukhriz,1,Randy Mckenzie,3,Rape Zombie: Lust of the Dead,1,Rape Zombie: Lust of the Dead 2,1,Red Persimmons,1,Rei Sakamoto,1,Reipu zonbi: Lust of the dead 3,1,Reviews,64,Reviews.,1,River of Exploding Durians,2,Roger Lee,1,Ronja,1,Ryu Kaneda,1,Ryuki,1,S. Korea,20,S.Korea,1,Saayak Santra,2,San Diego Asian Film Festival,3,Sanjeewa Pushpakumara,2,Sankha Ray,6,Satan's Slaves,1,Satoshi Kon,1,Say Yes,1,Sayandeep Bandyopadhyay,2,Scarlet Heart,1,Score,1,Sea Fog,1,Seijun Suzuki,3,Sexy S.W.A.T. Team,1,Shake Rattle and Roll,1,Shaw Brothers,1,She's the Boss,1,Shift,1,Shigeru Umebayashi,1,Shikhar Verma,3,Shikhar Verna,2,Shim Sung-Bo,1,Shinichi Fukazawa,1,Shinji Iwai,1,Shinji Sômai,1,Shinjuku Swan,1,Shinjuku Triad Society,1,Shinsuke Ogawa,1,Shinya Tsukamoto,2,Shôhei Imamura,1,Shoot for the Contents,1,Shorts,8,Shuna Iijima,1,Shutter,1,Siddiq Ahamed,1,Sidi Saleh,1,Signature,1,Sinophone,1,Sion Sono,4,Sixth Sense Hooker,1,Sogo Ishii,1,Soichi Umezawa,1,Sompot Chidgasompongse,2,Song Hae-sung,1,Song of the Week,19,Sopawan Boonnimitra,1,South Korea,15,Sri Lanka,2,Still the Water,1,Strange Circus,1,Studio Ghibli,1,StudioCanal,3,Subenja Pongkorn,1,Suffering of Ninko,1,Suicide Club,1,Sunao Katabuchi,3,Sung-hong Kim,1,Susumu Hirasawa,1,Tadashi Nagayama,1,Tae Guk Gi,1,Takaaki Hashiguchi,1,Takashi Miike,4,Take Care of My Cat,1,Takuro Nakamura,2,Tatsumi Kumashiro,1,Tetsuo the Iron Man,1,Tetsuya Mariko,1,Tetsuya Nakashima,1,Thailand,7,That's It,1,The Bad,1,The Boy and the Beast,2,The boy from Ipanema,1,The Crawler in the Attic,1,The Dollhouse,1,The elephant and the sea,2,The Executioner,1,The Forest Whispers,1,The Good,1,The Inugami Family,1,The Isthmus,1,The Kid from the Big Apple,1,The King of Pigs,1,The Man Without a Map,1,The Muse,1,The Naked Island,1,The Night of the Earthquake,1,The Outlaws,1,The recipe,1,The Road Home,1,The Road to Mandalay,1,the Robber's Daughter,1,The Room,1,The Sacrament,1,The Salesman,1,The Snow King,1,The Sower,2,The Story of the Disappearance of Maryam,1,The Strange Saga of Hiroshi the Freeloading Sex Machine,1,The Suicide Chain,1,The Tokyo Night Sky is Always the Densest Shade of Blue,1,The Weird,1,Tôkaidô Yotsuya kaidan,1,Tokyo Heaven,1,Tokyo Idols,1,Tokyo Vampire Hotel,1,Tolerance Film Festival,1,Tom Waller,1,Tony Leung,1,Toronto International Film Festival,1,Toshiaki Toyoda,1,Toshio Matsumoto,1,Toshiya Fujita,1,Traces of Sin,1,Train to Busan,1,Tran Ham,1,Trinh T. Minh-Ha,3,Twilight Dinner,1,Twitch: You Are My Toy,1,Uncovered,1,Vampire Clay,1,various,2,Victor Vu,1,Vietnam,2,Vikram Zushi,1,Violated Angels,1,Vital,1,West North West,2,Whispering Corridors,1,White Sun,1,Whore Angel,1,Wiman Rizkidarajat,1,Without Memory,1,Wol-Ha: Very Bad Moon Rising,1,Woman of the Lake,1,Woo Ming Jin,1,Yamato (California),3,Yang Ik-june,1,Yang Jong-hyeon,1,Yeon Sang-ho,2,Yiu-wai Chu,1,Yoshishige Yoshida,1,Yoshitaka Mori,1,Yoshiyuki Kishi,1,Yosuke Takeuchi,2,Yotsuya kaidan,1,Your Name,1,Yu Aoi,2,Yu Irie,1,Yûji Tajiri,2,Yuki Tanada,1,Yusaku Matsumoto,2,Yutaka Ikejima,3,Yuya Ishii,1,Zen,1,Zhang Yimou,1,Zoo,1,Zuairijah Mou,1,
ltr
item
Asian Film Vault: China’s Cultural Reverse Course: From Independence to Patronage in Unofficial Media Production
China’s Cultural Reverse Course: From Independence to Patronage in Unofficial Media Production
Matthew D. Johnson writes about the current state of documentaries in China
https://3.bp.blogspot.com/-nOHppSBd9hc/WauqOW2uhyI/AAAAAAAANgQ/ItxqyL2swMgQnyayXjHjNcptqLORhxv0wCLcBGAs/s320/johnson.jpg
https://3.bp.blogspot.com/-nOHppSBd9hc/WauqOW2uhyI/AAAAAAAANgQ/ItxqyL2swMgQnyayXjHjNcptqLORhxv0wCLcBGAs/s72-c/johnson.jpg
Asian Film Vault
http://www.asianfilmvault.com/2017/09/chinas-cultural-reverse-course-from.html
http://www.asianfilmvault.com/
http://www.asianfilmvault.com/
http://www.asianfilmvault.com/2017/09/chinas-cultural-reverse-course-from.html
true
3944800929692556231
UTF-8
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS CONTENT IS PREMIUM Please share to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy