What Time Is It There? (2001) by Tsai Ming-liang

A closer look on Tsai Ming-liang's classic


‘My films have been labeled “slow, boring, queer, colorless, anticlimactic, opaque…” Is it praise? Slander? What can I say?’- Excerpt from Tsai Ming-liang’s interview on Slant Magazine in 2015.

To be honest, I’ve witnessed the very same labels ‘tagged’ on works of art that refuse to be adjusted in any kind of artistic norms. Moreover, works of art which prefer to step out of this, somehow, enforced ‘political’ correctness by being skillfully evasive. Such bodies of work impose their own evolution of life-force by moving away from certain chronological timeframes and geographical zones, visual palettes, moods and environments, production or technical values.

Buy This Title

Therefore, all I can say is that once you enter Tsai Ming-liang’s universe, this life-force is channeled through a vision of originally innovative, as much as essentially nostalgic, cinematic expression. One of these rare occasions where an artist is bound to place himself between multiple ‘worlds’ and chronological layers, in order to play the ‘sensor’ part on behalf of an audience which is willing to receive a great number of ‘fluid’ emotional landscapes. Such landscapes, most of the times, cannot be easily described in plain words or, eventually, be analyzed as solid dogmatic showcases. It sounds a bit cliche but it kind of resembles the proverb ‘an image is worth a thousand words’ where you can replace the term ‘words’ with what suits the occasion better. Then again, one doesn’t exclude the other, which means that nothing can prevent anyone from presenting an idea in a fully dogmatic manner and having an equally effective impact as an outcome, regarding the viewer’s psyche. I suppose this is another hint among a vast number of reasons that make cinema such a popular and exciting form of art. Plus, there is always a space to debate but no time for pompous excommunications, as these are constantly cancelled by the nature of the medium itself.

In this particular case, a proverb, no matter how refined it may sound, it can only seem like an understatement in order to make an exact point regarding the cinematic philosophy of the 59 year old Malaysian auteur. Ming-liang is chronologically placed among the ‘second new wave’ creators of Taiwanese cinema. A breed of filmmakers (like Ang Lee) who arrive just in time, during the early 90’s, to pick up the torch passed to them from seriously gifted visionaries like Edward Yang and, of course, the living legend that Hou Hsiao-Hsien is. By that time, these tremendous creators were already writing their own wondrous cinematic history. Every person who appreciates Asian filmmaking at its finest should watch Hou Hsiao-Hsien’s 1993 hypnotic, masterful biopic "The Puppetmaster" or Yang’s breathtaking epic that ‘A Brighter Summer Day’ is.

Still from Hou Hsiao-Hsien’s masterful biographical drama ‘The Puppetmaster’, 1993

‘Second new wavers’ find themselves experimenting by focusing on a more universal and independent approach of filmmaking, given the fact that the foundations are already set in the best possible way. They graciously succeed by playing an absolutely fundamental part regarding the evolution of contemporary Chinese film industry. However, this was just the beginning. More than 20 years have passed and nowadays Ang Lee is considered as one of the greatest filmmakers on the face of the planet. Ming-liang is feeling at home with the likes of European cinematography. In 2015, right after the release of his ‘Stray Dogs’, Ming-liang implied that he is going to retire. I would love to think that such a scenario is not going to happen while his films attract a great amount of cinema aficionados.

His sixth full length creation among a filmography of eleven full length films, eleven short ones and about ten more TV movies and documentaries, is titled ‘What Time Is It There?’. It was released in 2001 under the umbrella of a French – Taiwanese co-production.

Kang-sheng Lee as Hsiao-kang watching Truffaut’s ‘The 400 Blows’

During the opening sequence we watch an old man sitting peacefully by himself, smoking a fag. At some point he will just stand up to call out on his son. The frame ‘opens’ and automatically it acquires geometrical depth while we watch the man moving outside. In the following sequence, we watch his son inside a car. He is mourning as he is on his way to hold a burial ceremony. He is carrying the old man’s remains.

This old man - a father, a husband and literally a travelling spirit, which will be ‘found’ somewhere between the geographical limits of Taipei and Paris, appears for about less than ten minutes throughout the film. Moreover, he is the ‘key’ that Ming-liang will use in order to unlock his 3 main character’s alienated feelings. His spirit is the invisible compass through which the audience will wander between Ming-liang’s ‘emotional’ landscapes. The 'affected' characters are his aforementioned son, Hsiao-kang, a salesman who owns a stand with hand watches in the streets of Taipei, Hsiao-kang’s mother (the old man’s wife), and a girl named Shiang-chyi.

The aforementioned, thoroughly minimal opening sequence, which lasts about 5 minutes, is a small sample of Ming-liang’s cinematic style. This style is practically used in the largest part of his film and is accompanied by sparse dialogue and steady shots, which occasionally ‘open’ through human motion and interaction. Of course, one could mention quite a few creators who implement such cinematic styles. You may receive an essence that brings in mind shots which vary from T. Angelopoulos’ long takes and ‘nouvelle vague’ cuts to Fellini’s dreamlike atmospheres, next to Antonioni’s alienating quests. There is a difference in this case, though. This difference comes in the form of a certain and very personal resonance that comes out through Ming-liang's sequences. This kind of resonance oozes in the form of a circular narrative style starting in the opening sequence to end up in the closing one. Ming-liang is undoubtedly a contemporary maestro who loves to play by his own rules. We must also note here that this kind of narrative is not here to serve some kind of plot twist. Even though his films may seem slow paced or giving an impression of a somehow seamless narrative, the truth is that everything revolves around an amazingly poetic and philosophical axis. This basis is empowered by amazing technical virtues, like the seminal use of photography and lightning or his use of beautiful camera angles.

Yi-Ching Lu as the grieving wife is waiting for a sign from the ‘other side’

We are introduced to Hsiao-kang’s mother, a housewife, who is found in some kind of heavy existential crisis, right after the death of her husband. A woman who starts losing touch with herself and her son. She is found in a state of denial as she is eagerly waiting for a sign. She is still cooking for him, putting food at his side of the table. She is holding a series of rituals in order to keep his spirit at ease. She has a short but desperate monologue with him through the aquarium fish he left behind. We must note here that all this comes with respect to the Buddhist beliefs regarding life after death. Although someone may speculate that Ming-liang finds these ideas somehow old fashioned and dated (this mostly happens through Hsiao-kang’s reactions against his mothers ritualistic outbursts, which are enforced upon his presence inside the house) he is not interested in projecting such actions in a somehow degrading way. That would be too predictable. Instead, he prefers to show a valid, more realistic contradiction between two worlds. A contemporary and a more traditional one, the mother and the son both found in a transition caused by this situation. Each one of these worlds has its share of chaos. What I really found fascinating, as much as meaningful, is that these two worlds do not cancel each other. This certain conflict is not taking place just for the sake of it. On the contrary, it seems like it serves as a vehicle, in order to comprehend aspects of the characters’ psychology at a very certain chronological point.

The third character is a young girl, who has no connection with the family, whatsoever. She is being introduced through an interaction with Hsiao-kang. She appears as a potential client who wants to buy a watch that the salesman has already stripped around his wrist. At first, he refuses to sell it while he mentions that this would bring bad luck because of his recently deceased father. She insists, while she stresses that she is a Christian, meaning such kind of beliefs do not ‘touch’ her. Plus, she has got to leave for Paris the very next day. After a bit of a bargain she finally buys Hsiao-kang’s watch. By the time she arrives in Paris, we start following her somewhere between her wandering through the streets of Paris and some occasional sightseeing. We often watch her inside her room. She starts hearing some noises coming from the upper floor. She seems lonely and quite homesick. At first, she doesn’t seem to care about interactions, though she becomes the receiver of a couple of flirtations. The first one is sort of implied and it is taking place inside a cafe. A man is obviously staring at her while she tries to appear indifferent in a very ‘nouvelle vague’-like atmosphere. The second one comes with a cameo from the legendary Jean-Pierre Leaud (who has also a few other passages as Antoine Doinel while Hsiao-kang starts having an almost sudden fixation on Truffaut’s alter ego by watching ‘Les 400 coups’ on repeat) in a beautiful sequence which takes place inside ‘le Cimetiere du Montparnasse’. The third one is more complicated and far more revealing, concerning Siang-chyi’s character. It comes at a point where she feels somehow worn out and obviously alienated, homesick and worried. A feeling she can’t even define by her own self. She becomes physically ill while she is at a restaurant. There, she meets a friendly young woman from Hong-Kong who lives in Paris. The woman helps her and after a friendly chat, we watch Shiang-chyi at her place. What follows is a kind of mishap between the two women, which takes place in a triple, seminal sequence. But I will come back to this point.

Jean-Pierre Léaud’s and Shiang-chyi Chen’s encounter

In between these two female characters, Hsiao-kang is experiencing his own major crisis. This kind of crisis includes a constant fixation with time, clocks and French cinema. He is in a constant search for clocks around the city, big or small, digital or mechanical. Clocks found in cinema corridors or even at the top of buildings. He constantly sets them according to the local time in Paris. It’s either that or watching Truffaut’s ‘The 400 blows’ and being caught within his mother’s mournful and hot-tempered mood. He has also a few bizarre encounters with a couple of characters. A minor incident with a strange guy who looks like he’s following him around since the moment he notices Hsiao-kang picking clocks inside a store, and a second and quite serious one with a prostitute. These sequences, which indicate a few funny notes, can be seen as tragic, at the same time. Nevertheless, they are presented in a quite offbeat way.

Towards the end and through an amazing sequence, Ming-liang synchronizes his 3 main characters by showing each one of them during a kind of sexual intercourse (or at least an attempt to have one). This comes out in a more redeeming rather than sensual approach. Hsiao-kang’s intercourse with the prostitute in which she ends up stealing his merchandise, his mother giving herself an orgasm next to her deceased husband’s photograph and Shiang-chyi in a failed attempt to make love with the Hong-Kong girl she meets in Paris. These three different shots come out as a single sequence. This is the point where these seemingly different characters release a kind of pressure and frustration that follows them until that moment. There’s no apparent motive driven by sexual desire, though it’s not exactly clear. I have the impression this is more about the alienation itself. In fact, it feels more like an act of despair in a way. Each one of these characters needs to find a way to humanize his or her alienated feelings and what is more natural than touching or being touched through someone. It does not matter whether it is real or inside their heads. Thus, this is the sequence in which all three characters finally find a small crack through their introverted, dreamlike microcosm. It almost feels like an alternate universe. We don’t know details about their past and as a result it seems like all three of them entered this world right after the old man’s death. It is like they are found in a kind of transcendence or something is keeping them in such a state.

What comes as a result for each one of the characters, right after the aforementioned sequence, is a kind of internal as much as external kind of peace. They seem more relaxed, serene. This is where Ming-liang ideally closes the perfect circle into which his narrative is slowly wrapped around and this is where we meet the old man once again. This time we obviously meet him as a spirit. This is happening while we watch Shang-chyi sleeping on a chair by a small pond in a Parisian park. Her luggage is floating on the surface of the water. A truly magnificent shot, as the movement is there through the floating luggage, while at the same time it emits a relaxing stillness. In the meantime, Ming-liang cuts through the other side of the pond revealing the old man’s spirit which slowly fades away from the screen, moving towards a wheel in an amusement park. One of the most brilliant closing sequences I have ever had the pleasure to watch inside a theatre.

Still from the closing sequence of the film

The performances by Ming-liang’s main triplet are astonishing, to say the least. Khang-sheng Lee as the troubled Hsiao-kang, Yi-Ching Lu as his mother and Shiang-chyi Chen as the tourist are so naturally simplistic but so effortlessly convincing, all at the same time. This triplet is present in almost all of his films, especially Khang-sheng Lee who is by his side since 1989 and his TV debut ‘All the corners of the world’. Having watched almost his entire filmography, I can say that once you allow yourself to slip inside his cinematic universe, you can easily notice how flexible these performers really are. We are talking about demanding roles accompanied by strong physical performances, plus a very certain rhythm in order to be synchronized with Ming-liang’s unique tempo, which follows each one of his features. For example, it is really fascinating watching Shiang-chyi Chen playing the estranged tourist in "What time is it there?" while in his following feature, the mesmerizing "Goodbye Dragon Inn", we are watching her moving at the pace of a snail, almost crawling, in order to perform a crippled girl, wandering in every single corner of a cinema which is about to shut down.

On the whole, "What time is it there?"’ is a bittersweet film about loss and denial. It is a film about urbanism and alienation, which, exactly like a travelling ghost, tries to get a hold on to human figures. Some people wish to escape from it, so they create their own parallel realities, some desperately provoke it and some think they can get away from it. Unfortunately, it is everywhere. In addition, it is an exceptional cinematic game between space and time and how these dimensions separate but also collide within the human spirit. Though there is stillness and the characters move in a seemingly certain timeframe, we get the sense of a constant movement like time-travelling. The thing is that Ming-liang is encouraging us to wander within this, almost, metaphysical dream, rather than unkindly waking us up or even throwing a bit of light by trying to point fingers and give any kind of answers. Those who seek answers in such questions may look somewhere else because this is a place for dreamers. One of the great things though, is that everything is taking place without losing touch from an underlying modern philosophical skepticism. This trait is bringing the balance between the real and unreal. There is room for both worlds. This combination comes in a very sweet but also sad way. It is poetic and utterly cinematic at the same time.

As an overall effect, all these reasons answer the question why Ming-liang’s films come off as some of the most elegant, really meaningful cinematic love letters I have ever had the pleasure to receive as a viewer. I really hope he has a few more left to send because the receiver is definitely there.




Here is the link for the very interesting interview he gave on Clayton Dillard and Slant magazine: http://www.slantmagazine.com/features/article/interview-tsai-ming-liang

COMMENTS

Name

13 Assassins,1,13: Game of Death,1,1428,1,2012,1,2015,1,2016,2,2017,11,2046,1,2LDK,1,3-Iron,1,36th Chamber Of Shaolin,1,500M800M,1,A Better Tomorrow 2018,1,A Bittersweet Life,1,A Bride for Rip Van Winkle,1,A Company Man,1,A Day,2,A Death in the Gunj,1,A Dirty Carnival,1,A Feeling Greater Than Love,1,A few words about us,1,A Girl at my Door,1,A Lonely Cow Weeps at Dawm,1,A Love,1,A Man of Integrity,1,A Man Vanishes,1,A Quiet Dream,1,A Simple Life,1,A Single Rider,1,A Special Lady,1,A Stone from Another Mountain to Polish Your Own Stone. Go Shibata,1,A Taxi Driver,1,A Whale of a Tale,1,A Woman Wavering In The Rain,1,Aamir,1,Abacus: Small Enough to Jail,1,Abdullah Mohammad Saad,3,Abhishek Chaubey,1,About Elly,1,Above the Clouds,1,Adam J. Symchuk,14,Adam John,6,Address Unknown,1,Aditya Vikram Sengupta,1,Adoor Gopalakrishnan,2,Adriana Rosati,9,Ae Dil Hai Mushkil,1,Age of Innocence,1,Age of Shadows,1,Ahmed Lallem,1,Ajantrik,1,Akihiko Shiota,2,Akira Kurosawa,1,Akiyuki Shinbo,2,Alan Lo,1,Alan Mak,1,Ale Amout,1,Alex Oost,1,Alfed Cheung,1,Ali Asghar Vadayeh Kheiri,1,Alipato,1,Along with the Gods: The Two Worlds,1,Amir Masoud Aghababeian,1,Amir Muhammad,2,Amit Madhesiya,1,Amit V Masurkar,1,Amitabh Reza,1,Amma Ariyan,1,Anand Singh,8,Anantaram,1,Ananya Kasaravalli,1,Andrew Thayne,8,Andrew Wong Kwok-huen,1,Andy Lau,1,Andy Willis,1,Anime,2,Animesh Aich,1,Ann Hui,5,Anna Bliss,3,Anqi Ju,1,Anthony Pun,1,Antiporno,2,Anurag Basu,1,Anurag Kashyap,1,Anysay Keola,1,Apocalypse Child,1,Arang,1,Ariyuki Shinbo,1,Armour of God,1,Aroused by Gymnopedies,1,Arrow,4,Art Film Fest Kosice,10,Asamapta,1,Asghar Farhadi,1,Asha Jaoar Majhe,1,Asian Classics,50,Atanu Ghosh,1,Aya Hanabusa,1,Aya Itabe,1,Aynabaji,1,Baby Ruth Villarama,1,Badrul Hisham,1,Badrul Hisham Ismail,1,BAMY,2,Bang Rajan,1,Bangkok Dangerous,1,Bangkok Nites,1,Bangladesh,7,Banjong Pisanthanakun,1,Battle of Memories,2,Battleship Island,1,Bauddhayan Mukherji,3,Bayin,1,Before We Vanish,1,Begum Jaan,2,Behind the Camera,1,Belgium,1,Ben Stykuc,7,Bengal,2,Bengali,8,Benny Chan,1,BFI,1,Bhutan,4,Big Boy,1,Big Tits Dragon,1,Billy Joe,2,Birdshot,2,Blade of the Immortal,1,Bluebeard,1,Boat People,1,Bollywood,5,Branded to Kill,2,Breathless,1,Broken Sword Hero,1,Bunny Drop,1,Burma,1,Burning Birds,2,Bystanders,1,Byun Sung-Hyun,2,Call of Heroes,1,Cambodia,7,Camera Japan,10,Cannes Film Festival,5,Céline Tran,1,Chang,1,Chang Tso-chi,1,Chang Zheng,1,Chen Hung-i,2,Chen Kuo-fu,1,Chen Mei-Juin,1,Cheung Yin-kei,1,Children Heaven,1,China,51,China Blue,1,China Yellow,1,Chinese Policy Institute,7,Chinese Shadows,4,Chinese Visual Festival,1,Ching-lin Chan,1,Chiu Sin Hang,1,Cho Sun-ho,1,Choi Jin-ho,1,Choi Jin-won,1,Choi Min-sik,1,Chookiat Sakveerakul,1,Chris Berry,1,Chronicles of Hari,1,Chung Ji-young,1,Chung Mong-Hong,1,CineAsia,1,Cinemawala,1,Claire's Camera,1,Close-Knit,3,Cloudy,1,Cocolors,3,Coffeemates,1,Cold Fish,1,Colette Balmain,13,Colour of the Game,1,Come Drink With Me,1,Competition,1,Confessions,1,Contact Info,1,Corey Yuen,1,Creative Visions: Hong Kong Cinema,1,Criminal City,1,Crocodile,1,Cyrano Agency,1,Daguerreotype,1,Daigo Matsui,1,Daihachi Yoshida,1,Daisuke Gotô,1,Daisuke Miyazaki,3,Danny and Oxide Pang,1,Dante Lam,1,Dark Side of the Light,1,David Chew,6,David Chew.,1,David Shin,1,Davy Chou,1,Dawn of the Felines,1,Dawn Wind in My Poncho,1,Ddongpari,1,Deadly Outlaw: Rekka,1,Dear Zindagi,1,Deepak Rauniyar,1,Derek Hui,2,Derek Tsang,2,Destruction Babies,1,Diary of June,1,Dibakar Banerjee,1,Dileesh Pothan,1,Ding Shen,1,Ding Sheng,1,Documentaries,27,Documentary,3,Doenjang,1,Don Anelli,24,Double Life,1,Double Vision,1,Dr. Heo,1,Dragonfly Eyes,1,Duckweed,1,Duelist,1,Dust of Angels,1,Eastern Promises,1,Eddie Cahyono,1,Edmund Yeo,2,Eiji Uchida,3,Eliana,1,Emma aka Mother,1,Enter the Warriors Gate,1,Erich Khoo,1,Erik Matti,1,Erotic Diary of an Office Lady,1,Eternal Summer,1,Eureka,6,Exploitation,34,Explosion,1,Fabricated City,1,Fantasia International Film Festival,24,Far East Film Festival,1,Fatal Countdown: Reset,1,Fathers,1,Features,21,Feautures,1,Fel,8,Fermented,1,Festivals,18,Filmddo,1,Filmdoo,16,Fires on the Plain,1,Fireworks,1,Fireworks Should We See It from the Side or the Bottom?,2,Five Flavors Festival,3,Five Flavours,13,Five Flavours Festival,11,Florence Chan,1,Flying Fish,1,Forbidden Door,2,Fove Flavours,1,France,3,Fraser Elliott,1,Free and Easy,3,Fruit Chan,1,Fujian Blue,1,Fullmetal Alchemist,1,Fumihiko Sori,1,Funeral Parade of Roses,1,Funuke Show Some Love,1,Fuyuhiko Nishi,1,Gangs of Wasseypur,1,Gareth Evans,3,Gauri Shinde,1,Geng Jun,3,Ghafara Harashta,1,Giddens Ko,1,God Man Dog,1,God of War,1,Godspeed,2,Godzilla: Planet of the Monsters,1,Going the Distance,1,Golden Cousin,1,Golden Horse Awards,1,Golden Slumbers,1,Gordon Chan,1,Grab the Sun,1,Guo Jian-yong,2,Gurgaon,1,Haibin Du,1,Han Han,1,Hanae Kan,1,Hanging Garden,1,Hanuman,1,Haobam Paban Kumar,1,Hapkido,1,Happiness,1,Happy Together,1,Harikatha Prasanga,1,Harishchandrachi Factory,1,Hashiguchi Takaaki,1,Haunters,1,Have A Nice Day,1,HBO,2,Heart Attack,1,Helldriver,1,Hello Goodbye,1,Hemlock Society,1,Her Own Address,1,Herman Yau,4,Hidden Gems,67,Hideen Gems,1,High-Kick Girl,1,Highheels,1,Hindi,7,Hirobumi Watanabe,1,Hirokazu Koreeda,3,Hiroshi Shoji,1,Hiroshi Teshigahara,1,Hiroyuki Kawasaki,1,Hiroyuki Seshita,1,Hisayasu Sato,1,HKETO,1,Ho Yuhang,2,Holy Island,1,Hong Kong,34,Hong Kong Godfather,1,Hong Sang-soo,2,Hongkong,1,Horror,1,Hou Hsiao-hsien,1,Hsu Hsiao-ming,1,Huang Fend,1,Huang Hsin-Yao,1,Huang Hui-chen,1,HUANG Xi,1,Huang Ying-hsiung,1,Hwang Dong-Hyuk,1,I Am A Hero,1,I Saw the Devil,1,I Wish,1,I-Lin Liu,15,Icarus Films,7,Im Kyeong-soo,1,Imtiaz Ali,2,In a Defiled World,1,In the Absence of the Sun,1,In this Corner of the World,2,Inchul Lee,1,India,48,Indonesia,16,International Film Festival Rotterdam,11,Interview,3,Interviews,44,Inugami,1,Ip Man: The Final Fight,1,Iran,8,Isao Yukisada,1,Ishqiya,1,J.P. Sniadecki,1,Jaatishwar,1,Jab Harry Met Sejal,1,Jackie Chan,4,Jagat,1,Jagga Jasoos,1,Jailbreak,4,James Mudge,1,Jang Chang-won,1,Jang Hoon,1,Japan,196,Japan Cuts,15,Japan Film Festival Australia,1,Japan Filmfest Hamburg,16,Japan Foundation Touring Programme,1,Japan the Emperor and the Army,1,Japanese Film Festival Australia,2,Jean-Marc Therouanne,1,Jean-Paul Ly,1,Jeong Byeong-gil,1,Jeong Jae-eun,1,Jeong Yun-Cheol,1,Jero Yun,1,Jesse V. Johnson,1,Jet Leyco,2,Jia Zhangke,1,Jigoku,1,Jimmy Henderson,3,Jithin K Mohan,7,Joby Varghese,1,Joe Odagiri,2,John Abraham,1,Johnnie To,2,Johnny Ma,1,Joko Anwar,6,Jonathan Cianfrani,1,Jonathan Wilson,8,Jonathan Yi,1,Joo Ji-hong,1,Josh Parmer,1,Journey of the Tortoise,1,July Jung,1,Jun Ichikawa,1,Jun Li,1,Jun Tanaka,3,Jung Byung-gil,2,Jung Sik,1,Jung Yoon-suk,1,Junichi Kajioka,2,Junk Head,1,K-dramas,11,Kaasan Mom’s Life,1,Kala,1,Kaneto Shindo,2,Kang Je-gyu,1,Kang Yoon-Sung,1,Kara Hui,1,Karan Johar,1,Katsuya Tomita,1,Kaushik Ganguly,1,Kazuya Shiraishi,1,Kei Chikaura,1,Kei Ishikawa,1,Keishi Otomo,1,Keishimi Oto,1,Ken and Kazu,1,Kenichi Watanabe,1,Kenji Yamauchi,1,Kentaro Hagiwara,1,Kfc,2,Khavn,2,Khosla Ka Ghosla!,1,Khushboo Ranka,1,Khyentse Norbu,1,Kill me,1,Killing Beauty,1,Kim Bong-han,1,Kim Eun-hee,1,Kim Hong-Sun,1,Kim Hyun-seok,1,Kim Jee-woon,4,Kim Jong-Kwan,1,Kim Joo-hwan,1,Kim Ki-duk,5,Kim Kih-hoon,1,Kim Min-suk,1,Kim Seong-hoon,1,Kim Whee,1,Kim Yong-hwa,1,King Hu,1,Kingyo,1,Kirti Raj Singh,1,Kiss me,1,Kiyoshi Kurosawa,4,Kôbun Shizuno,1,Kodoku Meatball Machine,1,Koji Fukada,1,Koji Wakamatsu,1,Kon Ichikawa,2,Konkona Sen Sharma,1,Konrad Aderer,2,Korea,1,Kotoko,1,Kristina Aschenbrennerova,1,Krzysztof Pietrzak,1,Kun-Yu Lai,14,Kung Fu Yoga,1,Kwak Kyung-taek,2,Kyoko Miyake,2,Kyriacos Kyriacou,3,Labour of Love,1,Lady of the Lake,1,Lady Snowblood,1,Laos,2,Lawrence Ah Mon,1,Le Binh Giang,2,Le Bình Giang,1,Leandro E. Seta,2,Lebanon,1,Lee An-gyu,1,Lee Byung-Hun,1,Lee Je-Yong,1,Lee Joo-young,1,Lee Jung-sun,1,Lee Kyoung-mi,1,Lee Myung-se,1,Lee Sa-rang,1,Lee Seo-goon,1,Leon Lai,1,lesbian,1,Leste Chen,3,Leung Wing-Fai,1,Ley Lines,1,Li Cheuk-shing,1,Life on the Line,1,Like Father,1,Like Son,1,Lim Sang-yoon,1,Lists,10,Little Big Soldier,1,Little Shop of Grotesque,1,Liu Jian,1,Liu Yang He,1,Liu Yulin,1,Live from Dhaka,2,Live Up To Your Name,1,London Korean Film Festival,5,Los Angeles Indian Festival,11,Lost Serenade,1,Love,1,Love and Other Cults,3,Lovely Man,1,Lovers Are Wet,1,Lowlife Love,1,Lucky Kuswandi,1,Lyberis,2,Machines,1,Mad Tiger,1,Mad World,4,Made in Hong Kong,1,Madman,2,Majid Majidi,1,Makoto Shinkai,1,Malayalam,3,Malaysia,8,Mamoru Hosoda,1,Manish Gupta,1,Manny Araneta,2,March Comes in like a Lion,1,Maria Georgiou,24,Mario Cornejo,1,Mark Gallagher,1,Marlina the Murderer in Four Acts,1,Mary Jirmanus Saba,1,Masaaki Yuasa,2,Masaan,1,Masahiro Shinoda,1,Masaru Konume,1,Masato Harada,2,Masato Ozawa,2,Masatoshi Kurakata,1,Matt Cooper,15,Matthew D. Johnson,1,Matthias Hoene,1,Maundy Thursday,1,Mayurakshi,1,Meghe Dhaka Tara,1,Memoir of a Murderer,1,Merantau,1,Mermaid,1,Michael Haertlein,1,Michelle Hung Tsz-ching,1,Midi Z,1,Midnight Runners,1,Midori Impuls,1,Midori The Camelia Girl,1,Mikhail Red,3,Milk the Maid,1,Ming-Yeh Rawnsley,1,Mira Nair,1,Miss Zombie,1,Miwa Nishikawa,2,Mohammad Rasoulof,1,Mohammad-Reza Lotfi,1,Mon Mon Mon Monsters,1,Mong-Hong Chung,2,Monika S-r,1,Monologue,1,Moon Lovers,1,Mototsugu Watanabe,3,Mouly Surya,1,Mountains May Depart,1,Mourning Forest,1,Movie,2,Moving,1,Mr. Socrates,1,Mrs Fang,1,Mrs K,1,Mukti Bhawan (Hotel Salvation),1,Mumon: The Land of Stealth,1,Museum,1,My Beloved Yak,1,My Dad and Mr Ito,1,Myanmar,1,Nah Hyeon,1,Nandita Roy,1,Naoko Ogigami,3,Naomi Kawase,3,Naosuke Kurosawa,1,Naoyuki Tomomatsu,3,Nawapol Thamrongrattanarit,1,Neeraj Ghaywan,1,Neko Atsume House,1,Neomanila,1,Nepal,1,Neuchâtel International Fantastic Film Festival,1,New Neighbor,1,News,3,Newton,1,Nicholas Poly,4,Night Bus,1,Night is Short,1,Night is Short Walk on Girl,1,Nikkatsu,1,Nikola Cekic,1,Ninja Pussy Cat,1,Nirbaak,1,Niwatsukino Norihiro,1,Noboru Uguchi,1,Nobuhiro Yamashita,2,Nobuo Nakagawa,2,Nobuyuki Takeuchi,2,Noise,1,Non-fiction Diary,1,Norbu,1,Norihiro Niwatsukino,1,Norjmaa,1,Norman England,1,North Korea,2,Nurse Diary: Beast Afternoon,1,NYAFF,34,Odd Obsession,1,Old Boy,2,Old Stone,1,Old-School Kung-Fu Fest,3,Omar Rasya Joenoes,3,On the Job,1,On The Line Festival,3,On the Run,1,Onibaba,1,Operation Red Sea,1,Ophilia,1,Ordinary Person,1,Osamu Sato,1,Our Happy time,1,Our Time Will Come,1,Outrage Coda,1,Over the Fence,1,Oxide Pang,1,Padmavati,2,Palatpol Mingpornpichit,2,Pale Flower,1,Panos,1,Panos Kotzathanasis,195,Paresh Mokashi,1,Park Chan-wook,2,Park Hoon-Jung,2,Park In-je,1,Park Ki- hyung,1,Park Kwang-hyun,1,Parkpoom Wongpoom,1,Past and Future,1,Patrick Hofmeister,53,Pedro Morata,8,Peerachai Kerdsint,1,Pelden Dorji,1,Pema Tshering,1,Pen-Ek Ratanaruang,2,Peng Xiaolian,1,Pepe Diokno,1,Perfect Blue,2,Peter Chan,1,Peter Chen,1,Phanumad Disattha,1,Philippines,11,Pieter - Jan Van Haecke,3,Pieter-Jan Van Haecke,6,Pink Eiga,9,PinkEiga.TV,1,pinku eiga,1,Pinneyum,1,Poet on a Business Trip,1,Poolside Man,1,Posto,1,Press Release,2,Proshoon Rahmaan,2,Psychic,1,Rabbit and Lizard,1,Radiance,1,Rage. Lee Sang-il,1,Rahul Jain,1,Railway Sleepers,1,Rainy Dog,1,Raja Mukhriz,1,Rajkumar Gupta,1,Randy Mckenzie,4,Rape Zombie: Lust of the Dead,1,Rape Zombie: Lust of the Dead 2,1,Rape Zombie: Lust of the Dead 3,1,Ravine of Goodbye,1,Re:Born,1,Real,1,Realism,1,Red Beard,1,Red Persimmons,1,Resistance at Tule Lake,1,Revenge: A love story,1,Review,6,Reviews,214,Reviews.,2,Riri Riza,3,Ritwik Ghatak,2,River of Exploding Durians,1,Robin Weng,1,Roman Porno,1,Rouge,1,Running on Karma,1,Russia,1,RV: Resurrected Victims,1,Ryoo Seung-wan,1,Ryota Sakamaki,1,S. Korea,64,S.Korea,2,Saayak Santra,9,Sabrina Baracetti,1,Sabu,3,Salaam Bombay,1,Samui Song,1,San Diego Asian Film Festival,13,Sanjay Leela Bhansali,2,Sanjeewa Pushpakumara,2,Sankha Ray,28,Satan's Slaves,2,Satoru Hirohara,1,Satoshi Kon,3,Satyajit Ray,1,Say Yes,1,Sayandeep Bandyopadhyay,6,Scarlet Heart,1,Score,1,Seijun Suzuki,3,Sekigahara,1,Sexy S.W.A.T. Team,1,Sha Po Lang,1,Shanjhey Kumar Perumal,1,Shanker Raman,1,Shaw Brothers,1,She's the Boss,1,Shiboprosad Mukherjee,1,Shigeru Umebayashi,1,Shikhar Verma,11,Shikhar Verna,3,Shinji Somai,2,Shinji Sômai,1,Shinjuku Swan,1,Shinjuku Triad Society,1,Shinobi no Kuni,2,Shinsuke Ogawa,1,Shinsuke Sato,1,Shinya Tsukamoto,3,Shireen Seno,1,Shirley Abraham,1,Shock Wave,1,Shôhei Imamura,1,Shorts,2,Shotaro Kobayashi,1,Shu Qi,1,Shunji Iwai,2,Shutter,1,Shyam Ramsay,1,Siddiq Ahamed,1,Sidharth Bharathan,1,Signature,1,Singapore,1,Singh Anand,1,Singing Chen,1,Sinophone,1,Sion Sono,8,Siti,1,Sixth Sense Hooker,1,Slavemen,1,Sleep Curse,1,Small Talk,1,Sogo Ishii,2,Solitude,1,Solo,1,Someone To Talk To,1,Sompot Chidgasompongse,2,Song Hae-sung,1,Song Kang-ho,1,Song of the Week,18,Sopawan Boonnimitra,1,Soul,1,SoulMate,2,South Korea,16,Sri Lanka,3,Srijit Mukherji,7,Stanley Kwan,1,Stanley Tong,1,Stephen Chow,1,Stephen Fung,2,Steve James,1,Still the Water,1,Stoneman Murders,1,Story in Taipei,1,Strange Circus,1,StudioCanal,3,Subenja Pongkorn,1,Suffering of Ninko,2,Sugihara Survivors: Jewish and Japanese,1,Suicide Club,1,Suman Mukhopadhay,1,Summer Snow,1,Sun-ho Cho,1,Sunao Katabuchi,2,Sunday Beauty Queen,1,Sung-hong Kim,1,Susumu Hirasawa,1,Tadashi Nagayama,1,Tae Guk Gi,1,Tag,1,Taiwan,24,Takaaki Hashiguchi,1,Takahide Hori,1,Takao Nakano,1,Takashi Miike,9,Take Care of My Cat,1,Takeo Kikuchi,2,Takeshi Kaneshiro,1,Takeshi Kitano,1,Takuro Nakamura,2,Tamura Senichi,1,Tanit Jitnukul,1,Tanvir Ashraf,1,Tatara Samurai,1,Tatsuhi Omori,1,Tatsumi,1,Tatsumi Kumashiro,1,Teddy Soeriaatmadja,1,Teenkahon,1,Tetsuya Mariko,1,Tetsuya Nakashima,1,Thailand,18,Thanatos Drunk,1,That's It,1,The Adventurers,2,The Apology,1,The Bad,1,The Boy and the Beast,3,The boy from Ipanema,1,The Chase,1,The Cinema Travellers,1,The Crawler in the Attic,1,The Crazy Family,1,The Day After,1,The Detective,1,The Dollhouse,1,The elephant and the sea,1,The Executioner,1,The Eye's Dream,1,The Forsaken Land,1,The Fortress,1,The Gangster's Daughter,1,The Girl Who Never Knew War,1,The Golden Fortress,1,The Good,1,The Great Buddha+,1,The Great Passage,1,The Hole,1,The Inugami Family,1,The Iron Ministry,1,The Island That All Flow By,1,The Isthmus,1,The King of Pigs,1,The Last Executioner,1,The Last Painting,1,The Long Excuse,1,The Magic Blade,1,The Man Without a Map,1,The Mayor,1,The Merciless,2,The Mermaid,1,The Muse,1,The Naked Island,1,The Net,1,The Prison,1,The Raid,1,The Raid 2,1,The recipe,1,The Road Home,1,The Road to Mandalay,1,The Room,1,The Salesman,1,The Sleep Curse,1,The Sower,2,The Story of the Disappearance of Maryam,1,The Strange Saga of Hiroshi the Freeloading Sex Machine,1,The Swindlers,1,The Table,1,The Third Murder,1,The Thousand Faces of Dunjia,1,The Tiger: An Old Hunter's Tale,1,The Tokyo Night Sky is Always the Densest Shade of Blue,1,The Tooth and the Nail,1,The Truth Beneath,1,The Villainess,3,The Violin Player,1,The Weird,1,The Windmill Palm Grove,1,Third WIndow,1,This Is Not What I Expected,1,This Is Not What I Expected!,1,Thondimuthalum Driksakshiyum,1,Three Sisters,1,Three Times,1,Tiffany Hsiung,1,Tôkaidô Yotsuya kaidan,1,Tokyo Ghoul,1,Tokyo Heaven,1,Tokyo Idols,1,Tolerance Film Festival,1,Tom Waller,2,Tony Leung,1,Tony Takitani,1,Torico,2,Toronto International Film Festival,1,Toshiaki Toyoda,2,Toshihisa Yokoshima,3,Toshimasha Kobayashi,1,Toshio Matsumoto,1,Toshiya Fujita,1,Town in a Lake,1,Traces of Sin,1,Trailers,62,Train to Busan,1,Tran Ham,1,Translated articles,1,Trapped,1,Travellers and Magicians,1,Triple Threat,1,Tsai Ming-liang,2,Tulsi Ramsay,1,Twilight Dinner,1,Twitch: You Are My Toy,1,Typhoon Club,1,Um Tae-hwa,1,Unbowed,1,V.I.P.,1,Vampire Cleanup Department,1,Vanishing Time A Boy Who Returned,1,Vannaphone Sitthirath,1,various,1,Varnyathil Aashanka,1,Vesoul International Film Festival,6,Vidya Balan,1,Vietnam,4,Vikramaditya Motwane,1,Vimukthi Jayasundara,1,Vinay Shukla,1,Violated Angels,1,Visitor Q,1,Vital,1,Vitaly Mansky,1,Voyage to Terengganu,1,Wai Ka-fai,1,Walk on Girl,1,Wang Bing,2,Wang Lung-wei,1,Wang Ming-tai,1,Warriors of the Dawn,2,Wei-Hao Cheng,1,Wellgo USA,1,West North West,2,What A Wonderful Family 2,1,What Time Is It There?,1,Whispering Corridors,1,Whispering Star,1,White Sun,1,Who Killed Cock Robin,1,Whore Angel,1,Wilson Yip,1,Wine War,1,With Prisoners,1,Woman of the Lake,1,Won Shin-Yeon,1,Wong Chun,3,Wong Jing,1,Wong Kar-wai,2,Woo Ming Jin,1,Xaisongkham Induangchanthy,1,Xu Bing,1,Ya-che Yang,1,Yamato (California),3,Yan Pak Wing,2,Yang Ik-june,1,Yang Jong-hyeon,1,Yao Tian,1,Yeon Sang-ho,2,Yes Madam,1,Yeti Obhijaan,2,Yiu-wai Chu,1,Yoji Yamada,1,Yoo Ha,1,Yoon-chul chung,1,Yoonsuk Jung,1,Yosep Anggi Noen,1,Yoshihiro Hanno,1,Yoshihiro Nakamura,2,Yoshihiro Nishimura,3,Yoshimasa Jimbo,1,Yoshinari Nishikori,1,Yoshishige Yoshida,1,Yoshitaka Mori,1,Yoshiyuki Kishi,1,Yosuke Takeuchi,2,Yotsuya kaidan,1,You Losers!,1,Your Name,1,Yu Aoi,2,Yu Irie,1,Yu Sang-wook,1,Yuen Chor,1,Yuen Woo-ping,1,Yuji Shimomura,1,Yûji Tajiri,2,Yujiro Harumoto,2,Yuki Tanada,1,Yukihiko Tsutsumi,1,Yusaku Matsumoto,1,Yutaka Ikejima,2,Yutaro Nakamura,1,Yuya Ishii,2,Zakka Films,1,Zhang Lu,1,Zhang Yimou,1,Zombiology: Enjoy Yourself Tonight,1,
ltr
item
Asian Film Vault: What Time Is It There? (2001) by Tsai Ming-liang
What Time Is It There? (2001) by Tsai Ming-liang
A closer look on Tsai Ming-liang's classic
https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-FGM6xRCI6A8/WNlArY9I5yI/AAAAAAAABp8/0cLQ_eNXXjQ557E_Gwvlu2nRJr812JqJwCLcB/s640/WhatTimeIsItThere.jpg
https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-FGM6xRCI6A8/WNlArY9I5yI/AAAAAAAABp8/0cLQ_eNXXjQ557E_Gwvlu2nRJr812JqJwCLcB/s72-c/WhatTimeIsItThere.jpg
Asian Film Vault
http://www.asianfilmvault.com/2017/03/what-time-is-it-there-2001-by-tsai-ming.html
http://www.asianfilmvault.com/
http://www.asianfilmvault.com/
http://www.asianfilmvault.com/2017/03/what-time-is-it-there-2001-by-tsai-ming.html
true
3944800929692556231
UTF-8
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS CONTENT IS PREMIUM Please share to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy